HSR Second Requests: Response and Closing Decisions

Facing an HSR Second Request? Organize the response and reconcile statutory periods, timing commitments and closing conditions.

Alex Lubyansky · Published 2026-04-18 · Updated October 29, 2026

Request Engagement Assessment

A Second Request turns merger review into a production project and a closing-calendar decision. The buyer and seller need to understand what they must produce, who can certify compliance and which restrictions still prevent closing. Those questions affect financing, the outside date and the business people supporting the investigation.

Start with the actual request and signed commitments. A generic timeline can hide the distinction between the statutory waiting period and additional timing the parties agreed to observe. Antitrust counsel should reconcile both with the merger agreement and any court restraint before the deal team authorizes closing.

Understand what the Second Request changes

The FTC’s merger-review guide explains that the investigating agency can request additional information during HSR review. The request extends the waiting process while the parties respond and the agency evaluates the transaction. It can seek business documents, data and testimony relevant to competitive effects.

Separate receipt of the request from completion of the response. The agency’s questions define a substantial information-gathering task. Antitrust counsel should identify which entities, people, systems and records are implicated before promising a compliance date to the transaction team.

Read the request with the business people who understand the products and records. A defined term that looks clear to a lawyer may map awkwardly to the company’s sales database or organizational structure. Those differences belong in the scope discussion early, with a proposed explanation and supporting facts.

Keep merger review separate from operational integration. The parties still need advice on permitted pre-closing conduct and information exchanges. Use the pre-closing integration guide to identify topics for counsel; the actual restrictions and safeguards require transaction-specific analysis.

Create an accountable response team

Give antitrust counsel responsibility for interpreting the request and directing the legal response. Identify business owners for document systems, financial data, sales records and relevant personnel. The M&A team should maintain the connection to closing conditions, covenants and financing rather than trying to manage the specialist response through an undifferentiated closing checklist.

Assign a person to each information source

Map requested information to a system and a responsible employee. Record whether data can be exported reliably, whether fields changed during the relevant period and what explanation is needed to interpret them. Ask employees to preserve relevant materials under counsel’s direction and to report missing or inaccessible sources.

The collection team needs instructions it can carry out. Identify the records, date ranges, custodians and formats covered by the request and any agreed modifications. Counsel should resolve questions about privilege, preservation and sensitive material before an operational shortcut changes the response.

Track decisions as well as production volumes

A count of collected files gives a partial view of readiness. Maintain a decision log for scope changes, unresolved data questions, privilege issues and communications with agency staff. Record the owner and the evidence needed to resolve each issue. That log helps counsel assess whether the response is ready for the next milestone.

Negotiate scope using the business’s actual records

A useful scope proposal explains what the requested information means in the company’s systems and how a proposed modification would still answer the investigative question. Give counsel concrete facts about record availability, custodians, duplication and the practical burden of alternative approaches.

Prioritize changes that preserve a reliable substantive response. For example, ask whether a proposed data source captures the relevant transactions and whether an omitted field can be reconstructed accurately. Avoid treating a smaller production as an outcome independent of the agency’s information needs.

Document agreed modifications and distribute the operative instructions to the collection and review teams. A conversation with staff can leave different participants with different understandings. Counsel should establish what is agreed, what remains a proposal and how the response plan changes as a result.

If technology-assisted review is used, explain its role in the protocol. Technology-assisted review uses software to help identify potentially responsive material during document review. Its use here needs a process counsel can evaluate, including the applicable agency requirements and any agreed testing or validation. Software output still requires a defensible legal response process.

Keep statutory time separate from negotiated commitments

The FTC’s merger-review process guidance describes the usual post-compliance waiting period as 30 days, with a 10-day period for specified cash-tender and bankruptcy circumstances. These are legal process periods. Counsel must identify the applicable transaction category and the events that start the calculation.

A timing agreement can contain additional commitments about when the parties will close, provide notice or complete other steps. The FTC’s timing-agreement explanation, August 7, 2018 explains the distinction between those commitments and statutory expiration. Treat that publication as historical guidance on the distinction; inspect the actual current agreement for the obligations in your deal.

Build separate calendar entries for the statutory period, contractual commitments, court orders and merger-agreement conditions. Identify who confirms each date and what evidence supports it. A single cell labeled “HSR clearance” can conceal an outstanding obligation that affects closing readiness.

The closing team also needs to know what has changed. If certification timing moves, update financing commitments, consent schedules and outside-date analysis. Ask antitrust counsel to state which assumptions remain valid and which require renewed advice. Preserve the old chronology so that notices and amendments can be evaluated against the actual sequence.

Counsel should evaluate substantial compliance using the request, agreed modifications and completed work. The business team can supply facts about records and systems; the final legal assessment needs to account for the response as a whole. A large production by itself leaves questions about completeness and unresolved requests.

Maintain a response index that connects each requirement to the production or explanation addressing it. Record open issues and the reason counsel considers each resolved or still material. Keep data definitions and explanations alongside the datasets so reviewers can understand what the fields represent.

Review certifications and the authority of the people signing them. Give those individuals the information and process needed to support the statements they are asked to make. The signature step should reflect completed verification rather than become the first point at which someone sees a remaining collection problem.

If the agency challenges compliance or seeks additional information, maintain the actual correspondence and counsel’s response plan. The transaction calendar should reflect the resulting uncertainty. Avoid presenting a proposed certification date as a completed statutory trigger before counsel has confirmed the relevant event.

Use evidence to address the substantive concern

Production and persuasion serve related purposes. Ask counsel and economists to identify the agency’s competitive concern and the evidence that bears on it. Business explanations should connect to records that can be tested, including customer behavior, product characteristics and the transaction’s actual rationale where relevant.

Prepare employees for interviews or testimony under counsel’s direction. Identify the records they know, the assumptions in their analysis and any limits on their knowledge. Consistent preparation means helping the agency understand accurate information; it provides no basis to reshape facts into a preferred account.

Where the parties consider a remedy, evaluate the proposed business change with the people responsible for implementing it. A divestiture proposal can affect contracts, personnel, technology, financing and the buyer’s original deal model. Counsel should distinguish a proposed solution from an accepted and executable arrangement.

Keep decision-makers informed about the options that remain. Continued investigation, settlement discussions and litigation preparation can require different resources and transaction decisions. Identify the next decision point, the evidence expected and the authority needed to act rather than reporting only that review is continuing.

Resolve calendar changes before they become deal fatigue

Alex Lubyansky connects missed dates and repeated delays with deal fatigue and weak alignment at the front end. In a Second Request process, the practical application is to expose the calendar assumptions early. If substantial compliance moves, the parties need a decision about financing and the outside date while there is still room to act. Another status report saying the investigation is continuing leaves that commercial decision unanswered.

In this March 12, 2026 episode of the Leo Landaverde M&A Podcast, Alex discusses deal fatigue beginning at 27:39. The application here concerns transaction coordination; antitrust counsel determines the investigation’s legal requirements.

Read efforts covenants, remedy provisions, information-sharing terms and termination rights together. The signed allocation of regulatory risk determines which commercial questions belong with the buyer, the seller or both. Ask M&A and antitrust counsel to explain any tension between the response strategy and those commitments.

Review the outside date using the actual extension mechanics. Identify notices, conditions and any amendment needed if the investigation takes longer than the parties anticipated. The financing team should evaluate the same dates so that an available legal extension is considered alongside the funding position.

Coordinate information rights carefully. The seller, buyer, financing parties and advisers may each need updates, while confidentiality and competition safeguards can limit what they receive. Counsel should establish the permitted reporting process and any clean-team arrangements appropriate to the information involved.

Before closing, assemble a written readiness assessment. It should address the statutory waiting period, timing commitments, court restraints and applicable closing conditions. Expiration of a waiting period alone provides an incomplete answer where another restriction remains. The authorized decision-makers need counsel’s analysis of the combined position.

Scope the work and budget around identified tasks

A useful budget separates collection, review, data work, economic analysis and legal strategy. Ask advisers to explain the assumptions supporting each component and the changes that would require a revised estimate. A universal cost range leaves the transaction team without a way to evaluate its own request.

Track costs against completed work and unresolved decisions. If a data problem creates additional work, explain the problem and the alternative approaches. If a scope modification reduces work, record how the operational plan and budget change. Keep the response’s legal adequacy central to those decisions.

Acquisition Stars handles M&A transaction work and coordinates with independent antitrust counsel on specialist review. Bring the request, merger agreement, current timing commitments and proposed closing calendar to an engagement assessment. Identify the decisions for which your team needs advice and the people already responsible for the investigation.

For related transaction planning, review our M&A services. This article provides general information. Antitrust counsel must evaluate the current rules, agency communications and signed documents for the actual transaction.

Frequently asked questions

What does an HSR Second Request do?

It requests additional information for merger review and extends the waiting process while the parties respond and the agency evaluates the transaction. Counsel should assess the request and applicable legal requirements.

Does a timing agreement change the statutory waiting period?

Track statutory expiration separately from the parties’ signed timing commitments. Counsel must also check court restraints and merger-agreement conditions before advising on closing readiness.

How should a company budget for a Second Request?

Separate collection, review, data work, economic analysis and legal strategy. Ask advisers to identify assumptions and revise estimates when the request, agreed scope or work changes.

Legal counsel for this topic

Acquisition Stars handles M&A transactions nationwide and works with securities counsel on securities matters. Alex Lubyansky leads the M&A engagements.

Closest fit for this topic M&A attorney M&A attorney for mergers, acquisitions, and divestitures.